tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post5266125245332699196..comments2023-10-19T21:17:22.713+08:00Comments on Gidong - Noumad: Lagu tema KEMERDEKAAN MALAYSIA ke 55 kedengaran seperti LAGU Pujian di GEREJAUnknownnoreply@blogger.comBlogger24125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-42640906719568142732012-08-03T17:00:25.149+08:002012-08-03T17:00:25.149+08:00lagu Serukan Namanya lebih awal d cipta,uda 4 tahu...lagu Serukan Namanya lebih awal d cipta,uda 4 tahun dari lagu janji di tepati yang baru-baru saja di dengar pada tahun ini..Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-1972854934927292602012-08-03T16:03:38.791+08:002012-08-03T16:03:38.791+08:00persamaannya adalah dari melodinya. tidak telalu s...persamaannya adalah dari melodinya. tidak telalu sama la, cuma style lagu tu hampir2 seperti lagu rohani. pencita melodi lagu ni org kristian kali arr :D cuma rasa sedikit lain la, sebab lagu2 malaysia-melayu sebelum ni tidak ada yang bermelodi seperti ni hehe^^ 1st time ba ada mcmni..so, faham2 ja la. hihiAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-29814383894102844802012-08-03T10:48:42.211+08:002012-08-03T10:48:42.211+08:00Walaupun saya penykong kerajaan tetapi tidak dinaf...Walaupun saya penykong kerajaan tetapi tidak dinafikan memang ada persamaan antara dua lagu ini. Sigh ~Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-32178784902073114952012-08-03T09:52:52.180+08:002012-08-03T09:52:52.180+08:00What makes the song identical is that both are usi...What makes the song identical is that both are using:<br />1. same chord progression<br />2. same beat/count to enter each beginning of verse and chorus<br />3. same rhythmic genre - ie. pop-rock (maybe if they use keroncong or sumazau beat it would sound different...hahaha)<br />4. and slightly melodic similarity as each melody begins and ends with the 1st and 5th tone of the major scale.<br />if you could sing both song together they made a perfect choral canon or rondo when the indonesian song sounds more of chanting or decorative and the malaysian one is sustaining sound.<br /><br />Those people who get use to the indonesian song familiar among the SIB churches and charismatic-oriented congregations would found the malaysian song the deduction of words and melodic improvisation of the indonesian version.Borneo Boyhttp://gidong-noumad.blogspot.com/2012/07/lagu-tema-kemerdekaan-malaysia-ke-55.htmlnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-42596265079316413822012-08-02T10:26:32.494+08:002012-08-02T10:26:32.494+08:00Melodi memang dah ada persamaan, tp lagi teruk lir...Melodi memang dah ada persamaan, tp lagi teruk lirik lagu ni langsung tiada kena mengena dengan kemerdekaan, "masa untuk membalas budi" ??? wtf !!! ni lagu politik bukan lagu merdeka.Kacangnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-22199337127116621022012-07-31T09:42:10.024+08:002012-07-31T09:42:10.024+08:00setuju............setuju............Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-70479325924567214422012-07-31T09:40:12.277+08:002012-07-31T09:40:12.277+08:00malaysia negara islam baa...malaysia negara islam baa...Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-71632452112931214732012-07-31T08:47:56.163+08:002012-07-31T08:47:56.163+08:00tu peminpin terus lagi bagus..tu peminpin terus lagi bagus..Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-18709378410245772852012-07-31T07:10:24.134+08:002012-07-31T07:10:24.134+08:00Baik tukar lagula...ada pro kontra dh ni...utk keb...Baik tukar lagula...ada pro kontra dh ni...utk kebaikan semua baik tukarlah lagu tu...temapun mcm tak ngam je.....Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-4201165783238290102012-07-30T22:07:11.999+08:002012-07-30T22:07:11.999+08:00Memang pun ada persamaan ni .. kalau dengar lagu J...Memang pun ada persamaan ni .. kalau dengar lagu Janji Di tepati memang ada sama dengan lagu Serukan Nama Nya ..Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-16234436409270919812012-07-30T21:06:40.285+08:002012-07-30T21:06:40.285+08:00aikkk????untuk rangkap permulaan ja yg sama nie..k...aikkk????untuk rangkap permulaan ja yg sama nie..klu dengar betul2, memang agak beza..tp, ntah la klu sy yg x pandai dengar..Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-13462990350932960382012-07-30T20:24:44.573+08:002012-07-30T20:24:44.573+08:00apa lahh...sebiji ..KING OF CIPLAK! ! !...apa lahh...sebiji ..KING OF CIPLAK! ! !...Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-77907007946127765222012-07-30T09:16:49.598+08:002012-07-30T09:16:49.598+08:00Saya setuju dengan artikel ini. Lagu kemerdekaan h...Saya setuju dengan artikel ini. Lagu kemerdekaan harus lari dari unsur-unsur politik.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-85265719219525714072012-07-30T08:46:43.916+08:002012-07-30T08:46:43.916+08:00memang ada persamaan, tidak dapat dinafikan walaup...memang ada persamaan, tidak dapat dinafikan walaupun bukan semua sama sebab Janji Di Tepati ditambah rap . Lirik dia memang mengampu parti politik . Saya setuju lagu ini di ganti dengan lagu lain.Kerisputihnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-77475435002716318612012-07-29T20:22:07.088+08:002012-07-29T20:22:07.088+08:00For a start, i dont know what were they're thi...For a start, i dont know what were they're thinking composing such a crappy-idiotic lyrics, melody is quite good (frankly), although the lyrics cancelled out the groove and soul of the whole piece. And i have to agree with two of the comments here, that the resemblance of the beautiful Serukan NamaNYA and crappy janji ditepati is quite blur. I've been in the music industry for all my life, mainstream and gospel, but i can see only slight similarity between the two. Yes, i agree with bisa ular, that the first 2 lines of verses are similar. Even on the score, it is quite the same. But the beautiful gospel have 4 lines (lyrics) in the verses, and the bloody "theme song" have 3. I wont even touch the bar count, i'm just going to explain it simpler. And the chorus, heck, for all i know, the resemblance is more towards the song "hearts on fire" (rocky 4 soundtrack). Not quite the same, but the influences are there. And yes, if they did took some ideas from the gospel song, then Hallelujah, Praise the Lord.<br />p/s: and yes, my ear is find. and, still, the "janji whatever" song, is forever will be, just a pile of cow dung. (the lyrics.. may God help us)Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-23700537749114884862012-07-29T18:15:09.287+08:002012-07-29T18:15:09.287+08:00nanti saya dingar hehehenanti saya dingar heheheEric@Boyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15959705382696681491noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-18069451065993868922012-07-29T17:48:08.128+08:002012-07-29T17:48:08.128+08:00Memang sama ..Memang sama ..Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-64134398802651094832012-07-29T17:00:58.947+08:002012-07-29T17:00:58.947+08:00Memang sama , siapa yang cakap tidak sama bagus pe...Memang sama , siapa yang cakap tidak sama bagus pergi periksa telingaKataknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-4662829695999196122012-07-29T16:47:33.901+08:002012-07-29T16:47:33.901+08:00Saya rasa memang sama .. mereka hanya ubah beat di...Saya rasa memang sama .. mereka hanya ubah beat dia .. Puji Tuhan lagu ini didengari oleh non kristen juga .Bessynoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-80020051997898220762012-07-29T16:38:01.591+08:002012-07-29T16:38:01.591+08:00Err... mcm tdk juga sama butul.. first 2 line of v...Err... mcm tdk juga sama butul.. first 2 line of verses, sama la.. tapi yg lain, mcm ndak.. influence tu ada, tapi melody wise, tdk juga brapa la, tapi klu drg ciplak ini lagu dari lagu Serukan NamaNya, nah, mmg diakui, lagu2 gospel mmg cukup mantap la.. Praise Jesus.. Puji Tuhan, AlleluiaBisa Ularnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-14540898851327026232012-07-29T16:00:21.507+08:002012-07-29T16:00:21.507+08:00saya rasa tiada masalah..apasalahnya malaysia di b...saya rasa tiada masalah..apasalahnya malaysia di berkati dengan lagu ini :).....Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-77204017504847874382012-07-29T15:04:29.212+08:002012-07-29T15:04:29.212+08:00Gid...sy bukanny apa...tpi sy mo ckp jg....d greja...Gid...sy bukanny apa...tpi sy mo ckp jg....d greja sy lagu serukn namany selalu kena bawa....malahn sy pernah nyanyi masa pimpn praise n worship....sy rasa mmg tia sama la...dri segi rythm n melody mmg jauh....tempoh pun sy rasa mcm tidak sama ooo....Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-543647512926265002012-07-29T13:49:36.056+08:002012-07-29T13:49:36.056+08:00Biar laba semoga mereka diberkati!Biar laba semoga mereka diberkati!Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-504874643303179688.post-64314731612749755812012-07-29T13:45:59.449+08:002012-07-29T13:45:59.449+08:00Sama 100% !Sama 100% !Prihatinnoreply@blogger.com